New Toys & Puzzles

Filter
Here are our newly added toys and puzzles for 2021.
1003 products

Squishy Dumpling
$9.99
Starcube - Transforming Geometric Puzzle
$12.99
Racing Cat in Box - 1 random color
$4.99
Groaning Blobfish - Uhhhh!
$12.99
Finger Axolotl - 1 random color
$1.99
Murder of Crows - set of 4 figures
$6.99
Chicken Feet - SET of TWO
$3.99
Groov'n Bigfoot Eraser - 1 random color
$3.99
Finger Gecko - 1 random color
$1.99
Wind Up Wooly Walker
$9.99
Creepy Ants Prank
$1.99
Desktop Flikkin' Chicken Game
$10.99
A Bunch of Hocus Pocus 500 pc puzzle
$19.99
Cartesian Diving Jellyfish - Swims up and Down
$3.99
Solar System Net Bag of Marbles
$5.99
Reindeer Pen
$4.99
Jingle Hand Bells w/ Velcro - one random color
$3.99
Knuckle-Headz Pull back Race Car- one random style
$11.99
Spinz Pull back Race Car - includes ONE car
$11.99
D-Bag Poet - Magnetic Poetry
$12.99
Nerd Poet - Magnetic Poetry
$12.99
Jackalope Nodder
$11.99
Sale
Squishables Mushroom II 15"
$46.00 $42.99 Save $3.01
Extreme Base Jumper - 17" parachute
$6.99
Sale
Grow a Unicorn
$6.99 $3.99 Save $3.00
Astro Grow Pet - One Mystery Grow Pet Inside
$7.99
Ginormous Hatchin Grow Dragon
$7.99
Colorful Crawly Caterpillar
$3.99
We Are Colorful Skin Tone Colored Pencils
$9.99
Holiday Puzzle to Go Christmas Train 36pc
$9.99
Snowy Night 500 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$14.99
Pusheen #17 Mystery Box Pusheenicorns
$11.99
Spirited Away: Soot Sprites cling - 1.5"
$13.99
Tugl Cube
$15.95
Hot Diggity Dog Pool Float
$44.99
Fart Whoopee Cushion XL
$4.99
You are My Sunshine Music Box
$8.99
Invisible Pen Light
$4.99
Gimme That - Wild Fast Potato Fun!
$14.99
Baby Hedgehog Needle Felting Kit
$23.99
Sale
Squeeze Poop
$3.99 $1.59 Save $2.40
Santa Jack in the Box
$32.99
Sale
Dog Jack-in-the-Box
$35.99 $32.99 Save $3.00
Sale
Bunny Jack-in-the-Box
$35.99 $32.99 Save $3.00
Crags - Magnetic Fidget Putty (ages 13+)
$19.99
World's Smallest Slinky
$5.99
World's Smallest Minion's Fart Gun - It works!
$7.99
World’s Smallest Blind Box Series 4
$5.99